Is Cold Plunging Killing Your Gains? Let’s Get Serious

You may have heard the latest fitness horror story circulating on TikTok and Instagram:

Cue the dramatic music, the shocked reaction videos, and the well-meaning but misinformed bros yelling, “Don’t do it, man!”

As someone who cold plunges 5 to 10 minutes nearly every day—and still manages to maintain a solid physique, train hard, and recover better than I ever have—I figured it was time we have an actual conversation. A real one. With facts.

Because here’s the thing: Cold plunging isn’t the villain—it’s just misunderstood.

So let’s break it down:

• Where this scary-sounding statistic actually came from

• What the science really says about cold exposure and muscle growth

• And how you can use cold plunging the right way to recover better, without sacrificing gains

Let’s switch from virally misinformed to experimentally educated. (I made these words up) 😁

💪 What Really Happens When You Build Muscle

Before we talk about cold, let’s talk about muscle growth. Because if you don’t understand the game, how can you win?

Muscle hypertrophy is just your body’s response to stress. When you lift weights—especially heavy or with intensity—you create tiny micro-tears in your muscle fibers. That’s not a bad thing; that’s the point. Your body gets the signal: “Hey, that was a lot… better adapt.” So it rebuilds those fibers thicker and stronger.

There are two main kinds of hypertrophy:

• Myofibrillar hypertrophy: the kind that increases actual muscle fiber density. This is where you get stronger.

• Sarcoplasmic hypertrophy: increases muscle glycogen and fluid storage. This is more about size and the “pumped” look.

Now, here’s where the science gets really fun. Three key triggers drive hypertrophy:

1. Mechanical tension – Lifting heavy with good form

2. Muscle damage – Causing controlled trauma that leads to repair

3. Metabolic stress – The burn, the pump, the grind

When you lift, you trigger all three. Your body’s response? Send in the cavalry: satellite cells, inflammation, hormones, nutrients… everything needed to repair and grow.

And that is where cold plunging can either support you—or potentially interrupt the process.

🧊 So… Where Did the “66% Less Gains” Come From?

This number didn’t fall from the sky. It came from a 2015 study published in The Journal of Physiology that examined cold water immersion (CWI) and its effect on muscle adaptations.

In the study, researchers took two groups of athletes. Both did resistance training. But one group plunged into cold water—about 50°F—for 10 to 15 minutes immediately after training. The other group did light active recovery instead.

After 12 weeks, the CWI group had significantly less muscle hypertrophy and strength gains—around 66% less growth in some markers.

Now before you throw your cold tub out onto the street and light it on fire, let’s look at what’s really going on here.

The reason those athletes saw less growth was because cold exposure blunted the inflammatory response their bodies needed to start the repair and growth process.

It was like turning off the “build muscle” signal before it even had a chance to ring.

So yes—cold water can reduce muscle growth… if used at the wrong time.

📖 Want to geek out? Here’s the actual study:
👉 Cold Water Immersion Study (2015)

🧠 Timing is Everything (Cold Plunging Isn't the Problem)

The big myth in all this? That cold plunging in general kills your gains.

Wrong.

What the study showed is that cold plunging immediately after lifting can interfere with hypertrophy. But most of us aren’t hopping from the squat rack straight into the ice bath.

Personally? I usually plunge first thing in the morning to wake up my nervous system, or in the evening to help with recovery. Rarely—if ever—do I plunge right after a heavy lift for 10 minutes! But, I do typically jump in for :30 seconds to a minute, to rejuvenate.

And that’s the key. If you give your body the chance to respond to the workout—let inflammation, blood flow, and adaptation happen—then cold plunge later? You're good.

You still get the benefits of reduced soreness, better circulation, faster recovery… without sacrificing gains.

🧊✅ How to Cold Plunge Without Killing Muscle Gains

Here’s the actual protocol I recommend for anyone who wants to optimize for both muscle and recovery:

✅ Best Times to Cold Plunge

• 4–6 hours after lifting

• First thing in the morning or right before any workout

• After cardio or sauna sessions

• Long Plunge On non-lifting days to speed up recovery

❌ Avoid Cold Plunging…

• Immediately post-lift if your goal is size or strength

If you’re chasing hypertrophy, just give your body time to respond to the workout before you dive into the cold, or do it before the workout session.

🎯 So What’s the Real Takeaway?

Cold plunging isn’t killing your gains. Bad timing is.

You don’t have to pick between muscle and recovery—you just have to understand how to use your tools. That’s all this is.

I cold plunge almost every day. I lift, I recover, I sleep better, I manage stress, and I keep building. It’s not magic—it’s just strategy.

Let the inflammation do its job first. Then bring in the cold.

And hey—if you’re cold plunging just for recover, you’re missing the bigger picture.
You’ve got benefits like:

• Boosted dopamine

• Improved vagal tone

• Reduced inflammation

• Better sleep

• Lower resting heart rate

• And a huge mental resilience edge

Recovery is just one piece of the pie.

😏 Real Talk (And a Little Fun to Close It Out)

So no—cold plunging isn’t melting your hard-earned muscle off.

You can cold plunge and still be swole. You can optimize your nervous system and still bench heavy.

And if you’re still panicking because of one viral clip you saw on TikTok… maybe that’s what you should plunge away.

If this helped you out, shoot me a reply or forward it to a buddy who’s still afraid of the ice. Let’s keep building muscle, making smart decisions, and staying dialed in with our recovery.

📚 Sources for the Nerds Like Me:

• 2015 Study on Cold Water & Muscle Growth

• What Triggers Muscle Hypertrophy (NSCA Journal)

Want more content like this?
Join the newsletter fam here at "The Good Stuff"—where I share the real science behind what works, what doesn’t, and how to thrive in a world that’s overflowing with health hype.

Have a great day, and God Bless!